Finance Matters

Posts Tagged ‘economic growth’

In 1991, former MIT dean Lester Thurow wrote that “If one looks at the last 20 years, Japan would have to be considered the betting favorite to win the economy honors of owning the 21st century.”

He wasn’t alone. The standard view of the 1980s held that Japan’s sway over the world economy was unbreakable. Its economy grew faster. Its corporations were more efficient. Its workers more productive. In 1988, former Reagan official Clyde Prestowitz warned: “The American century is over. The big development in the latter part of the century is the emergence of Japan as a major superpower.”

Such comments are now ridiculed relentlessly by analysts and commentators, including myself. Japan, after all, did not boom. Far from overtaking the United States, its economic growth stagnated for two decades, its stock and housing markets collapsed, and its government entombed itself in debt. Twenty years ago, Japan was synonymous with the phrase “juggernaut.” Today, it’s often seen next to the phrase “lost decade.”

America should take notice, we hear these days. If we don’t get our act together, we could be in for a lost decade or two just like Japan.

But there’s an interesting rebuttal to these warnings by a Japan-based journalist named Eamonn Fingleton. He summarizes his views bluntly: “[A]fter studying the facts on the ground in Tokyo for decades I find it hard to avoid the conclusion that the story of Japan’s stagnation is a media myth.”

How so? Consider:

• The highest Japan’s unemployment rate has been in the last 20 years is 5.5%. Its current unemployment rate, 4.6%, is about half that of the United States. Among those of prime working age, unemployment is virtually nonexistent in Japan today.
• Japan’s average life expectancy at birth increased by more than four years — from 78.8 years to 83 years — between 1989 and 2009. Japanese, Fingleton points out, “now typically live 4.8 years longer than Americans,” and better health care is a major factor.
• Japan had a current account surplus of nearly $200 billion in 2010, up threefold in 20 years. By contrast, America’s current account deficit was nearly half a trillion dollars in 2010, up fivefold in 20 years. In short, Japan supplies the world with products and capital, while America supplies it with debt.
• Based on purchasing power parity, Japan’s income per capita has grown at nearly the same rate as America’s over the last 20 years (0.8% vs. 1%, respectively).
• According to the Japanese Statistics Bureau, during the “lost decade” of 1991-2001, the average Japanese citizen spent more time enjoying arts and culture, gardening, reading books, sightseeing outside the country, and visiting family.
• The yen has strengthened 87% against the dollar and 94% against the pound over the last two decades.
• Japan’s ranking in the world Corruption Perceptions Index has increased substantially over the last decade, and is now well ahead of the U.S.

The average Japanese citizen, in other words, is living longer, earning more money, spending more time in leisure activities, being better represented by government, and enjoying some of the highest job security in the developed world. If this is the narrative of a failed economy, sign me up.

Why the gulf between perception and reality? Part has to do with the standard metric we use to judge economy’s health: gross domestic product. Over the last two decades, Japan’s real GDP has grown at 1% a year, compared with about 2.5% for the United States. Clearly, Japan looks like the loser of the two countries.

But there’s a difference: Japan’s population is in decline, while America’s is rising. From 1990 to 2007, Japan’s working-age population fell from 86 million to 83 million, while America’s jumped from 160 million to 200 million. When GDP is measured on a per capita basis, the growth difference between Japan and America narrows by two-thirds. When viewed as GDP growth per working-age resident, the difference between the two nations virtually disappears. The size of Japan’s pie may not be growing as fast as America’s, but the amount of pie available to each citizen, and each worker, is plodding along at a similar rate.

Make no mistake: Japan’s economy faces unimaginable challenges because of its staggering debt load. Demographics magnify those dangers. “Japan is a bug searching for a windshield,” investor John Mauldin said two years ago — a comment that was probably as accurate as it was controversial.

But Fingleton’s points are valid, and highlight two important issues.

One, gross domestic product can be a poor way to measure an economy’s worth and progress. It counts things that don’t matter — a vague calculation of output — while ignoring how actual people on the ground are doing. In his book The Rational Optimist, author Matt Ridley shows how Africa frequently falls into the same trap. Judged by GDP growth, most of Africa looks like a pit of stagnation and decline. But using metrics that are actually meaningful to people — life expectancy, access to health care, clean drinking water, disease prevention, education, democratic representation — Africa has made incredible strides in recent decades.

Fingleton makes a somewhat analogous argument for Japan: “There’s a dramatic gap between what one reads in the United States and what one sees on the ground in Japan,” he quotes journalist William Holstein as saying. He continues: “The fallacy of the ‘lost decades’ story is apparent to American visitors the moment they set foot in the country. Typically starting their journeys at such potent symbols of American infrastructural decay as Kennedy or Dulles airports, they land at Japanese airports that have been extensively expanded and modernized in recent years.”

Second, misconceptions about Japan’s economy demonstrate how easy it is to assume something is accurate just because you’ve heard it ad nauseum. Admittedly, I’ve mentioned Japan’s lost decades in the past without asking whether there were another side of the story. I heard enough about stagnation and decline to assume it was all true. Not until I read Fingleton’s rebuttals did I look at the details and realize, to my shock, that he was right. What’s the saying? Trust, but verify.

Fingleton finished a recent essay with a note: “I feel so strongly about all this that I have more than once over the years challenged the principal proponents of the ‘lost decades’ story to a debate. I first tried in 1998; and then again in 2002. On each occasion there were no takers.”

Anyone care to step up to the plate?

This post originally appeared at The Motley Fool. 

Please follow Money Game on Twitter and Facebook.

Join the conversation about this story »

See Also:

• TREASURY TO INVESTORS: We Might Allow You To Pay Us To Hold Your Money
• One Dam Metaphor For The 2012 Global Financial System
• The 10 Worst-Performing Cities In The World

The UK economy needs a fiscal boost of £10 billion to £20 billion in order to avoid another recession, a leading think tank said today.

In its annual Green Budget, The Institute for Fiscal Studies calls for Chancellor George Osborne to include a short-term fiscal stimulus in his budget.

This would buffer the UK economy against the eurozone crisis and the possibility of another recession which could see GDP falling in 2012 and 2013, and a substantial increase in national debt.

The stimulus could take the form of a temporary reduction in employers’ National Insurance contributions or VAT, or could be achieved by increasing investment spending.

‘Should the eurozone break up, or the economy do much worse than forecast for other reasons, then future borrowing would be increased and one – or both – of the Chancellor’s fiscal targets would be broken,’ the IFS said.

The think tank has cut its forecast for UK economic growth to just 0.3 per cent, substantially lower than Government’s 0.7 per cent target.

The report claims that the scale of the government’s austerity strategy is “almost without historical or international precedent” but by the end of the current financial year only 6% of the cuts will have been implemented.

The government is expected to beat its 2011/12 deficit reduction target of £127 billion by £3 billion.

IFS director Paul Johnson said: “The Chancellor faces his third Budget with the economy and public finances in considerably weaker shape than he had hoped a year ago.

“While it looks as though central Government is going to underspend against tight spending plans, this neither leaves much space for any permanent fiscal loosening nor avoids the fact that the vast majority of the planned – and unprecedentedly big – public service cuts are still to come.”

There was also some good news on the economy today, with Markit’s/Cips’ purchasing managers’ index (PMI) revealing that the UK manufacturing sector has returned to growth.

In January, activity in the manufacturing sector was at its highest level for eight months, reaching 52.1 points on the PMI index, where a reading above 50 indicates growth.

This represent a significant improvement from 49.7 in December, with manufacturing output and new orders increasing while manufacturing costs fell.

Maybe Robert Shiller — who just told us that there’s no housing rebound on the horizon — is right.

His own housing index, the Case-Shiller Home Price Index, came out this morning, and it will dash the hopes of people who think we’re on the cusp of a rebound.

After a little blip upwards, prices resumed their downward slide in November.

Depressing.

Please follow Money Game on Twitter and Facebook.

Join the conversation about this story »

See Also:

• CHART OF THE DAY: Why Is The Baltic Dry Index Getting Crushed?
• CHART OF THE DAY: A Completely Random Correlation That Tells You Everything About This Market
• CHART OF THE DAY: ‘Core Economic Growth Slowed Sharply In Q4′

Without a doubt, 2012 has gotten off to a quieter-start than what we experienced during much of 2011.

That’s been a good thing, market-wise. In the vacuum we’ve watched equities mostly drift higher, European yields drift lower, and emerging markets roar back to life.

This week the headlines should be back with a vengeance. First, there’s going to be tons of news out of Greece, as the country and its creditors continue to hammer out a deal. There’s been all kinds of weird whispers in the background about maybe Greek preparing to leave the Eurozone and default, and mostly nobody has listened. But if the negotiations continue not to be successful, then those will get even louder. Then there’s the brewing Portugal question. Also, there’s a European summit. So expect headlines out of that.

Then in the US, we’re jam-packed with data, as it’s officially JOBS WEEK.

The Non-Farm Payrolls report comes out on Friday. Analysts expectations are in a range of 150-200K new jobs in January. The unemployment rate is seen falling to 8.4% from 8.5%.

But before that there’s tons of other data, including, of course, ADP, the measurement of private payrolls, on Wednesday.

Today we get personal income and spending and the core PCE price index, which will be closely watched for more signs of disinflation.

Case-Shiller and Chicago PMI come out Tuesday.

Also on Wednesday, ISM manufacturing is released.

Please follow Money Game on Twitter and Facebook.

Join the conversation about this story »

See Also:

• 2011 GDP: 1.7%
• The Simple Reason GDP Growth Was Such A Bummer
• CHART OF THE DAY: ‘Core Economic Growth Slowed Sharply In Q4′

BEIJING (AP) — China’s economic growth slowed in the final quarter of 2011 to its lowest rate in 2 1/2 years as U.S. and European consumer demand plunged and Beijing fought inflation.

The world’s second-largest economy grew by 8.9 percent in the three months ending in December, data showed Tuesday. It was the slowest expansion since the second quarter of 2009, when the economy grew 7.9 percent.

For the full year, the economy grew 9.2 percent, down from 2010′s blistering 10.3 percent after communist leaders tightened lending and investment curbs to prevent overheating and inflation.

Hit by an abrupt plunge in Western consumer demand, regulators reversed course in late 2011 and tried to prop up growth by promising more bank lending to help struggling exporters and avert job losses and the threat of unrest.

Also in 2011, China’s urban population exceeded the number of rural dwellers for the first time, rising to 51.3 percent of the nation’s 1.3 billion people, the National Bureau of Statistics announced.

Please follow Money Game on Twitter and Facebook.

Join the conversation about this story »

See Also:

• These Economies Will Dominate The World In 2050
• ALBERT EDWARDS: This Will Be The ‘Final Year Of Pain And Disappointment’
• China’s Inflation Cooled To 4.1% As Food Prices Heated Up to 9.1%